Mint 10

Doug Mills
552 days ago

I've been using the RC of Mint 10 or "Julia" if you prefer, for the last 4 weeks.

I decided to try it out on the HP laptop first, and all appeared to be well until I tried to use the wireless.  The connection would be made to the D-link router, would hold for approx 2 minutes and then would be lost.  The router was just a couple of meters away and the signal strength was shown as 100% during the times that the connection was made.

This cycle would repeat over and over again, with 2 minutes connection and a 30 second wait for a re-connection.  The HP never had this problem with previous installs (mint, ubuntu, fedora and sabayon), so I was sure this was a Mint 10 problem.   A quick look through the ubuntu forums found that I was not alone - the ath9k wireless driver (as used for many wifi cards) has some issues and from what I understand, something somewhere is triggering a re-set command to be sent to the wifi card itself.  I'd also tried 2 "patched" ath9k drivers, but same results.   I've gone back to Mint 9 for the moment and sent the associated bug reports.  Hopefully this problem will be resolved for the official release, as a laptop with no wifi is a bit naff.

On the the upside Mint 10 looks good and it's as fast as lightening.  After a bit of tweaking the laptop was booting up around the 15 second mark - not bad!   As you would expect from the Mint team, everything else was polished to perfection so the final release should be great.  Wireless woes aside, I would give the RC 8/10.

Scott Nichol
551 days ago

One thing that strikes me about various Linux distros is that there seems to be insufficient testing before the final release which results in problems like yours coming to light. I suppose it's to be expected when resources are limited.

Even when they are plentifull testing is often inadequate ( eg DOS 4.2, Windows ME, Windows Vista etc). I've just had to abandon Ubuntu 10.10 on my desktop machine because of frequent freezes and go back to 10.04.